As a rags-to-riches story, the Lemp family tale is like none other. Johann Adam Lemp left his home in Germany and emigrated to St. Louis in 1838. Back then the only beers available in the US were strong English ales. So Lemp, along with a Philadelphia partner, introduced the lighter German-style beer that has become America’s favorite.
Lemp discovered that the caverns underneath St. Louis acted as a natural coolant. That allowed him to ramp up production without spoilage, thus leading him to purchase a brewery and the Lemp Mansion over the caverns in which his beer was stored.
Although few have heard of it today, Lemp’s Falstaff beer became a success practically overnight, and was the most popular beer well into the 20th century, leading over second fiddle Anheuser/Busch’s Budweiser. But tragedy soon struck.
Johann died in 1862, leaving the business to his son William. In 1901, William’s son Frederick, who was to inherit the brewery, died suddenly from heart failure. When William’s best friend, Frederick Pabst, of Pabst Blue Ribbon fame, died in 1904, William became distraught. He shot himself in the head in the family mansion.
The mansion and business was then left to William’s son Billy. He sadly ran it into the ground, shuttering it abruptly in 1919. Soon after, he and his sister Elsa both committed suicide. Thirty years later, another of William’s eight children, Charles, shot his dog to death and then himself. He left a note simply saying, “In case I am found dead, blame it on no one but me.”
But rumors were sparked that the blame actually rested on the Lemp Mansion – that the house was haunted and possessed a curse under which Lemp family members suffered tragic deaths.